We live in a society that celebrates autonomy and independence. From childhood we are taught that becoming an adult means fending for ourselves, needing no one. Self-sufficiency is often seen as the minimum requirement for a life worth living, while dependence is considered a condition to be avoided or, worse, hidden away. In this scenario, there is no room for fragility or vulnerability.
Yet all it takes is a sudden event, an illness, an accident, a surgery, or simply the passing of time, for this belief to be called into question. Fragility, in fact, does not concern a minority of people: it concerns everyone.
Much of Martha Nussbaum's philosophical reflection starts from precisely this premise. The scholar criticizes the image of the human being as a fully autonomous, rational and independent individual, an image that has long shaped Western political and legal thought as well. According to Nussbaum, however, this representation is incomplete, because it overlooks an essential fact of human experience: we are all vulnerable, and any one of us, over the course of a lifetime, can experience forms of dependence on others.
Childhood is the clearest example: no one is born self-sufficient. But that same dependence can resurface during an illness, after an accident, in the course of aging, or in many other circumstances of life. Vulnerability, then, is not an exception reserved for certain people, but a defining feature of human existence.
This perspective also overturns the way we look at disability. If fragility belongs to everyone, then the person with a disability is not an exception to some presumed norm, but simply makes more visible a dimension shared by every human being.
For Nussbaum, a just society cannot be conceived by taking into account only perfectly autonomous citizens. It must instead recognize that people have different needs and requirements, succeeding in the task of ensuring that everyone can develop their own capabilities and participate fully in the life of the community. Inclusion, then, is not a concession granted to a minority, but a consequence of acknowledging our shared human condition.
Perhaps this is also why disability still sometimes makes us uneasy. Not so much because it seems distant to us, but because it cracks the reassuring image of a human being who is always efficient, productive and independent. It reminds us that absolute autonomy is often a fiction, not a permanent condition.
Embracing Martha Nussbaum's lesson, then, means changing how we view the nature of the human condition. It means recognizing that dependence does not diminish a person's dignity, and that vulnerability is not the opposite of normality, but one of the conditions that make human life possible. Only by starting from this awareness can we build a truly inclusive society, one capable of treating mutual care not as an exception, but as one of its fundamental values.