It isn't a book about disability, Città sommersa (Bompiani 2020) by Marta Barone, a splendid novel-biography that tells the story of a daughter searching for her father. A father with a name and surname, a father who was known, a father who was present—yet a father who dies before truly revealing himself to his twenty-four-year-old daughter. Because when, after his death in 2011, the young woman finds some court documents from a trial in the 1980s against the man (the charge was participation in an armed group), Marta Barone finds herself facing a wall of questions she must answer. And so, paradoxically, the death that took her parent away from her, in some way—precisely through that wall—gives him back to her (“I wish he could have told me this story himself. I wish I'd had the time to hear it. But in a sense, I'm aware that the book exists because the man is no longer here”).
On this journey to discover the life of her father Leonardo, and of Turin (page after page, the man and the city unfold before her, revealing sides always looked at but never truly seen), Marta Barone comes across the story of Villa Azzurra, the infamous children's asylum whose name was the only enchanting thing about it. As happened in most similar institutions scattered across the peninsula, the asylum took in children from illiterate or extremely poor families—children deemed “uneducable,” victims above all of a lack of opportunity, “treated” with atrocious cocktails of every kind of abuse: sexual, psychological, physical, medical.
The methods of the Turin asylum's chief physician, Giorgio Coda, stood out in particular (he would later be tried and convicted for mistreatment). “To let the most unruly children let off steam,” writes Marta Barone, “he made them fight each other like dogs in a pit, until they collapsed, injured and exhausted; but his specialty, the one that earned him the directorship of Villa Azzurra, was electroshock. That's why he would forever be known as the Electrician.” In July 1970, a photographer from L'Espresso managed to get inside the facility. “He wandered through the wards without anyone noticing. He photographed children who were tied up, covered in flies, expressionless (…) He photographed a girl named Maria, and her portrait became the lead image of the report. She had short hair, a gentle face, a completely naked body, and her wrists and ankles were bound as if in a crucifixion.” Years later, searching for her father, Marta Barone came across many survivors of Villa Azzurra, often “unable to free themselves from what the institution had done to them”—partly because, as often happens, after the scandal the children were released in a “random and senseless” way: betrayed twice, in other words. Some of these young patients had, since the 1980s, been cared for by a cooperative that Marta Barone knew well, because her father had worked there.
The story within the story of the former inmates of Villa Azzurra is not just a glimpse into the history of Turin, and of Italy as a whole: it's an important chapter in the story of Leonardo Barone. “If the part that comes after is missing,” says one of the many people the writer spoke to while writing Città sommersa—in this case, an old comrade of her father's—“the part where your father went to take care of the ‘mad’... it's as if a piece were missing, you understand? If he had given up, if he had really given up, he would have gone off to make money! (…) You have to understand that he didn't give up, Marta. He stayed, right to the very end, with the people he was meant to stand by.”
Raw and alive, this book by Marta Barone is a wonderful one—the kind that keeps humming inside you, accompanying you with the clear (and sometimes a bit prickly) strength of fragility. Of true fragility, the kind that carries life forward as it follows daughters and guides fathers; that carries life forward as it guides daughters and follows fathers.
Buy this book on one of the sites in the Helpfreely network.
If you're a member, a percentage of your purchase will be donated to Fede e Luce. (Find out more)
Here's where you can find it: